From deep-sea excursions to tranquil fly-fishing in shallow waters, here are the best Caribbean islands to visit for fishing, each providing unique opportunities to hook the catch of a lifetime.
1. The Bahamas

Renowned for its spectacular fishing, The Bahamas is undoubtedly one of the best Caribbean islands to visit for fishing. The surrounding waters are teeming with an impressive variety of fish, including marlin, tuna and dorado. Nassau, the capital, serves as a great base for deep-sea fishing excursions where you can test your skills against some of the ocean's most formidable creatures. For those who prefer something a bit more laid-back, the shallow flats of the Exumas offer world-class bonefishing opportunities. The crystal-clear waters make it easy to spot the swift bonefish, providing a thrilling challenge even for experienced fly fishers.
2. Cayman Islands

The Cayman Islands offer some of the most exciting fishing in the Caribbean. Grand Cayman is famous for its deep-sea fishing, where you can catch blue marlin, wahoo and tuna. The North Sound, a large shallow reef-protected lagoon, is ideal for catching tarpon and snapper, providing both quantity and diversity in your catch. Local charters are available for half-day or full-day trips, tailored to both novice anglers and seasoned pros looking to add a trophy fish to their collection.
3. Puerto Rico
Puerto Rico's diverse aquatic environments make it a top destination for anglers. The island's deep waters are accessible just a short distance from the shore, making it perfect for those looking to engage in deep-sea fishing without spending too much time traveling to fishing spots. Common catches include mahi-mahi, marlin and sailfish. Additionally, the backcountry waters offer excellent tarpon fishing, especially around San Juan and the northeast coast. Local guides can take you to the best spots where these silver kings are known to roam.
4. U.S. Virgin Islands
The U.S. Virgin Islands, consisting of St. Thomas, St. John and St. Croix, provide fantastic year-round fishing opportunities. St. Thomas is particularly noted for its "North Drop," a fishing hotspot known for its excellent blue marlin population. The island hosts several fishing tournaments throughout the year, which speaks to the quality of fishing experiences available. St. Croix offers a more diverse fishing experience, with opportunities to catch everything from bonefish in the shallows to big game fish in deeper waters.
5. Barbados

Barbados is a gem for fishermen looking for variety. The island's unique position in the Atlantic exposes it to deeper waters compared to other Caribbean islands, making it a fantastic place for big game fishing. Species such as barracuda, tuna and even shark are common, providing an adrenaline-pumping experience for those on the hunt for something extraordinary. For those who enjoy more tranquil fishing, the inshore waters offer plenty of snapper, grouper and other reef fish.
6. Belize
While technically in Central America, Belize's position on the Caribbean Sea makes it a prime fishing destination. Its barrier reef is the second largest in the world, providing an ideal habitat for a wide range of fish species. Ambergris Caye and the surrounding waters are particularly famous for offering one of the best flats fishing experiences in the world where you can pursue permit, tarpon and bonefish in clear, shallow waters. Belize’s commitment to catch-and-release fishing ensures the sustainability of its fish populations and reef health, making it a responsible choice for eco-conscious anglers.
Why Visit These Caribbean Islands For Fishing?
Each of these destinations offers something unique for anglers, making them the best Caribbean islands to visit for fishing. Whether you're looking for a trophy catch in the deep sea or a peaceful day casting in shallow flats, these islands offer world-class fishing with breathtaking scenery. The Caribbean’s warm waters and abundant fish populations ensure a rewarding fishing experience, while local charters and guides provide invaluable insights and access to the best spots.
Prepare your tackle box, set your sights on these Caribbean paradises and get ready to cast into some of the most fertile fishing grounds in the world. Each cast brings a chance for excitement and the thrill of a lifetime catch, making your Caribbean fishing adventure an unforgettable journey.